Photo by Dominic Chamot
Photo by Oliver Adell
DOMINIC CHAMOT, pianist
You won the first prize at the Viotti Competition. How does this kind of recognition impact your approach and expectations as an artist?
A lot of good things have happened since I was lucky enough to be awarded the first prize at the Viotti competition. But nowadays there are so many high-profile international piano competitions that the impact they have is significantly more limited than it used to be. Very few people will be able to tell you the names of the winners of the last two editions of the Chopin, Van Cliburn and Queen Elizabeth competitions. So I try to see it as one of (hopefully many more) stepping stones on the path that I’m on already now. I always say that the most beneficial aspect of taking part in a competition is the time of preparation. The moments leading up to the competition are the really valuable ones that will have a lasting impact on your artistic identity rather than the competition itself.
At a young age, you joined the Pre-College in Cologne. How do you think starting so early affected your musical development?
These early years of my ‘professional’ development have had a lasting impact on my artistic identity. I didn’t know it at the time but it was an immense privilege to have all of these subjects on this high level on a weekly basis at the Hochschule für Musik in Köln. My Pre-College lessons on counterpoint and harmony have been the most defining influences on my theoretical understanding of music. But especially the piano lessons with Prof Sheila Arnold were a gift I learned to appreciate only many years later. She not only managed to steer me through my naturally difficult teenage years with ease but also implanted in me the seeds for an endless urge to grow musically and to make music the center of my life. She never put any pressure on me to practice or perform, allowing me to find my individual approach to music. I believe that this is the main reason I now still enjoy my work as much as I did during these years studying with her.
You studied in Basel with Claudio Martínez-Mehner. What did you learn from that experience, and how did it change your perspective on music?
I studied with Claudio for six years.If you compare my pre-Claudio self to my post-Claudio self you wouldn’t think that it is the same pianist. Claudio’s way of understanding and teaching music is so unique and so politically incorrect that nobody can ever be immune to his influence, wether they like it or not. The problem I have with answering your question is that I can’t tell you what I learned from him, really. I know that he taught me most of what I believe in and that his approach is deeply engraved in me by now. But what exactly this approach is, I can’t put into words. After almost every lesson I would come out of the room feeling like my musical world view had been shattered. Only over the next few days it would slowly put itself back together, reshaped. This would repeat the next week in the next lesson. But through this very particular (and I believe, intentional) process, my progress had to be made mostly subconsciously. So even though I would consider myself a predominantly analytical kind of person, he managed to bypass that and access parts of my personality otherwise unused. If all of that sounds a bit strange, I’m sorry but that’s just what studying with Claudio is like.
What is it like for you to live in the city of Basel as a musician?
Basel is at the same time wonderful and very dangerous for a musician to live in. Sometimes it feels like a little bubble that has everything you need and is extremely comfortable. The cultural scene is immensely diverse and alive, especially considering the rather small size of the city. It is totally possible to make a living as a freelance musician in Basel. So that’s wonderful. But it also means that there is no pressing need to get out of it, to explore and to grow bigger than it. And so it is very easy to adjust your musicianship to the needs of the place rather than to the needs of your musicianship itself. Depending on your ambitions and aspirations this can be a very dangerous situation.
Photo by Dominic Chamot
You have worked both as a soloist and in collaboration with orchestras. Do you feel a different connection with the music in each context?
Playing solo and playing with orchestra are two very different musical realities. I love both passionately. In a solo recital there is a direct and uninterrupted connection between the music, me and the audience. There is the freedom to let yourself go completely and to let the moment decide what the music needs. The only thing that matters is the sound that the instrument produces and how it travels through the room into the audience. When playing with an orchestra there is the added element of playing together with a large number of musicians who all rely on your role as a leader. Some of the musicians (including the ones who have very important parts to play) sit very far away from you and in a position to which the piano doesn’t project very well. So there are some musical ideas that have to be sacrificed in order to create a real connection between the players by highlighting certain elements in the piano part that help to play together. But these sacrifices are made up by the endless possibilities that come with adding this huge body of sound to the stage. There is no feeling like a proper tutti climax in a Rachmaninoff concerto, when a huge crowd of people join you in blasting out pure emotion.
You teach at the Musikschule Riehen. What is the main advice you give to your students, and why?
Don’t play if you don’t feel like it. It’s the same advice I had to give myself at one point in my own life. In the moment that you vow never to force yourself, that’s when you start to really practice. Especially considering the insanely busy lives of the children and teenagers in Switzerland, who have to deal with pressure from school, plus an average of about two to three extra-curricular activities per day, music can easily become just another element of stress. But in my conception that goes against the very essence of music. How can you cultivate the love for this art if your main experience of it is one of discomfort?
If you could relive a performance with any legendary pianist, who would it be and why?
That’s almost impossible to decide. But if I had to choose, it would probably be Franz Liszt. First of all, there is no way that it wouldn’t be impressive to hear him play. If his compositions are anything to go by, he must have had the most unique and creative approach to the keyboard. His pieces are full of passages that are extremely weird and different from any other passage but at the same time very comfortable to play. So he must have understood something about playing the piano that nobody else did. On top of it there are just as many passages that seem completely unplayable! Now these I would really like to hear him play. In addition, there is so much discussion about how to play and how not to play his music (and the music of his time). I’m sure that we’d all be very surprised to hear how he would go about interpreting his own music. I believe it would be a life-changing experience.
Is there a piece you haven’t performed yet that is on your dream list?
Much more than one! Apart from all the piano repertoire that I love and don’t have the time to study I have some less realistic wishes of playing the Viola in Bach’s B minor Mass, the Cello in Brahms’ Symphonies, the Timpani in Bruckner’s Symphonies and to sing the Tristan. But we just have one life, don’t we?
Photo by Oliver Adell
Classical music continues to face challenges in reaching new audiences. What do you think the industry could do to revitalize interest in this genre?
I like Andras Schiff’s reply to this: We only believe that classical music is in a crisis because we compare it to pop music nowadays. If we compare how many people listen to Bach today, to how many listened to him during his time, it’s an amazing increase!
But I do believe that there is currently a struggle to market classical music to the generation of 20-50 years olds. There are a lot of kid’s and young people’s concerts and a lot of concerts that are comfortably attended by the older generation. But when we look at the daily routine of working adults we see that there is no way that they will go to a classical music concert in the evening after a workday of 8 hours, having to rush through their dinner to make it in time, just to be sitting silently in a room full of relaxed retired people. It just doesn’t sound fun. I believe that we need to add new formats of classical music concerts specifically shaped for the needs of this generation and we need to adjust the surrounding elements of the concerts to what they like. I’m thinking a regular weekend late night event with free booze and socialising opportunities, preferably including things like an Instagram photo wall. From my experience there is nothing wrong with the music itself, it is timeless and touches anybody who opens up to the experience. But in order to get people to open up for it, we need to put it in a context which is attractive from the point of view of the audience we want to reach.
In your opinion, how do social media platforms influence the life of a classical musician today?
I can only talk about my own experience, which is ambiguous. I have had some very positive experiences, including engagements for concerts based on my social media. But I actually have serious doubts about mental health regarding social media and especially considering artists and musicians promoting themselves on the platforms. The problem is the following: You need a lot of self-confidence to promote yourself, especially on social media. You will have to share recordings of music which is always a difficult task as there will rarely be a recording that you are completely happy with. But you need to cultivate a certain arrogance to stop yourself from overthinking and spending too much time choosing, editing, etc. This goes very much against my belief that as a musician you need a healthy balance between self-confidence and self-doubt. I think if you’re unbalanced, you make it much more difficult for yourself to improve. So that’s why I completely removed my access to any social media, except for when I need to post something. I’m still wondering if the time you put into it is worth the return you get…
What role should music education institutions play in preparing artists for the current challenges in the industry?
Most institutions are already offering a wide variety of preparatory classes including classes about music business, as well as specialised courses on orchestra playing, contemporary music etc. But I think the biggest challenge of them all is to make the students understand how important these classes actually are. Most music students (including myself back in the days) are overly idealistic in believing that music and art are the only things that matter and that even thinking about the business aspect of it will make you a worse musician. To an extent this is very sympathetic thinking, but it doesn’t really serve anybody, least of all the students themselves. I found myself after my studies frantically roaming the depth of my memories for informations I had picked up during my studies that I had considered useless at the time. If there is a remedy for this that the music education institutions could use, it would mean a big change in the music world, as it would tackle they way things have been going probably for a very long time already.
For you, what does success mean as a musician?
Success as a professional musician seems very measurable by exterior factors such as engagements, critics, accomplishments in different fields. But as an artist, I try not to think about success. Succeeding in something means reaching a goal, possibly one you set yourself earlier. The nature of music on the other hand is one of constant change, where achieving one thing just means opening multiple doors for further challenges. Sometimes during practice I catch myself feeling like I ‘figured out’ something. In these moments I have to remind myself that I only figured out how something worked in this specific moment, and that it might not work the next time I try, as my disposition will naturally be a slightly different one from the last time. So any feeling of achievement or success can only be valid in any present moment and therefore becomes irrelevant as a measure of absolute artistic growth.